A Journey to Islamorada

A Journey to Islamorada

The drive from Miami to Key West is one of the most spectacular road trips in the United States. As you cruise down Highway 1, you'll pass through Islamorada—a destination you definitely don't want to miss.

Whether you're just stopping by or planning to stay overnight, make sure to indulge in a meal at one of the finest restaurants in the area. Islamorada has become my favorite spot in the Florida Keys, offering a variety of exciting activities such as water sports, beautiful beaches, museums, and state parks. Best of all, it boasts an impressive selection of quality dining options.

1. Lorelei Restaurant & Cabana Bar

Lorelei is one of the most popular restaurants in Islamorada. In the mornings, local fishermen often stop by for breakfast. The crowd shifts throughout the day, with both locals and tourists flocking in for lunch and dinner. Many are drawn to its beachfront location and stunning sunset views, while live music in the evenings adds to the vibrant atmosphere.

At Lorelei, seafood reigns supreme, with dishes like Sunset Conch Fritters, Key's Conch Chowder, and Stone Crab Chowder. They even have a special kids' menu called Little Mates & Mermaids, featuring the famous world-renowned fish sandwich.

2. Chef Michael’s

Chef Michael’s is one of the top fine dining establishments in Islamorada, offering a sophisticated experience in a cozy island setting. It's the perfect spot for special celebrations like birthdays or anniversaries.

The menu features modern New American cuisine, always using fresh local ingredients. Chef Michael began his career at top restaurants in New York before moving to the Caribbean, where he has become a master of seafood preparation. Be sure to try one of the daily fresh fish specials, like Mahi Mahi or Yellowtail Snapper!

3. Square Grouper

Square Grouper is a fresh addition to the restaurant scene in Islamorada. This eatery serves New American cuisine in a traditional bar and grill atmosphere, making it an ideal place for delicious meals, especially if you're in the mood for a cocktail.

Signature dishes include Square Grouper Seafood Stew and Truffled Lobster Mac. You can enjoy your meal indoors or outdoors, and the restaurant is quickly gaining popularity.

4. Morada Bay Beach Cafe

Overlooking Florida Bay, Morada Bay Beach Café is a fantastic spot to kick back on the beach with your toes in the sand. This friendly and laid-back restaurant offers unbeatable views of the ocean.

Try the Island Cobb Salad or Fried Chicken Sando Island Style, and don’t miss out on seafood options like Mahi Mahi Tacos and the catch of the day. They also have non-seafood choices like Turkey Club and Beyond Burger.

5. Green Turtle Inn Restaurant

Green Turtle is one of the standout restaurants in Islamorada, known for its relaxed atmosphere and delicious flavors. They serve breakfast, lunch, and dinner, and are particularly famous for their breakfast offerings.

Breakfast options at Green Turtle are diverse, ranging from Lobster Benedict to pancakes and burritos. The restaurant has an interesting history, being one of the few buildings that survived the hurricane of 1935, and it features rich historical photos depicting life in Islamorada.

6. Ziggie & Mad Dog’s

Ziggie & Mad Dog’s is not only highly rated but also carries a piece of Islamorada's history. This establishment has been around since the 1930s and exudes a lively sports atmosphere. Here, you can savor some delicious beef dishes.

The menu at Ziggie & Mad Dog’s is extensive, featuring everything from duck and pork ribs to pasta, ensuring there's something for everyone.

7. Pierre’s

Pierre’s is one of the premier fine dining spots in the Florida Keys. It’s perfect for romantic dinners or special occasions, offering an intimate atmosphere with stunning sunset views.

The menu features French fusion cuisine with local influences, including dishes like seared scallops, lamb chops, and calamari. Downstairs, you'll find the Green Flash Lounge, an ideal spot for cocktails after dinner.

8. Ciao Hound

If you're craving a taste of Italy in Islamorada, Ciao Hound is a fantastic choice. This family-friendly restaurant features a lovely outdoor seating area.

They serve breakfast and dinner, with a rich menu that includes pasta. Don't miss the Lasagna Bolognese, and the Caprese Ravioli is also a must-try!

9. Islamorada Fish Company

Islamorada Fish Company is a fantastic beachfront restaurant to enjoy a meal. Here, you can watch the sunset while savoring fresh seafood.

The restaurant specializes in fresh seafood with a live seafood counter, featuring oysters, shrimp, and their famous stone crab claws. If you're not a fan of fish, your options may be limited here.

10. Bayside Gourmet

Bayside Gourmet is another well-known local restaurant offering high-quality Italian cuisine. If you're in the mood for pizza, this place has a rich variety of options to satisfy your cravings.

In addition to pizza, they also serve soups, salads, and many wonderful pasta dishes, along with gourmet sandwiches.

11. Mangrove Mike’s Cafe

Mangrove Mike’s is the perfect spot for a fantastic breakfast in Islamorada. They also serve hearty lunches with a diverse menu for everyone.

Popular dishes include wraps filled with a variety of ingredients like chicken, tuna, and vegetarian options. Every visit brings new discoveries at this delightful restaurant.